With a strong performance of equities in 2013, major market indices have reached peak levels. In an attempt at accuracy, many articles in the financial media adjust index values for inflation. The conclusion is that the market, as measured by the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA), has surpassed record levels from early 2000 only very recently on an inflation-adjusted basis. On the other hand, a broader market benchmark, the S&P 500® index, is still about 15% below its inflation-adjusted 2000 peak. Having suffered significant downturns in both 2000 and 2008, the NASDAQ-100 index is significantly below both its nominal and inflation-adjusted historical highs.
The problem is that in all of these assessments, a price level of each index is used. Would the findings be different if indices were also adjusted for reinvested dividends to account for total returns? To determine that, Alpholio™ compiled inflation- and dividend-adjusted prices of two representative exchange-traded funds: the SPDR® Dow Jones® Industrial Average ETF (DIA) and SPDR® S&P 500® ETF (SPY). These ETFs are long-lasting and popular implementations of their respective indices. To adjust for inflation, the Consumer Price Index – All Urban Consumers (CPI-U) was used.
A conventional price chart shows that DIA has indeed just matched an inflation-adjusted record high from January 2000:
However, a chart for DIA with reinvested dividends indicates that the previous inflation-adjusted peak from October 2007 was already surpassed in mid-January 2013:
Similarly, a price-only chart illustrates that SPY is still about 13% below its inflation-adjusted top from March 2000:
On the other hand, the chart with dividends factored in demonstrates that SPY already exceeded the previous inflation-adjusted maximum level in May 2013:
According to S&P Capital IQ, since the late 1920s dividends constituted about 45% of the total return of the stock market. Therefore, any assessment of the current market level has to adjust not only for inflation but also for reinvested dividends. From that standpoint, historical market peaks were quietly surpassed much earlier this year. Time and again, media focus is on generating simplified headlines rather than noting true events.